Universities as Subjects of International Relations: The Potential of Kyrgyzstan

   Against the backdrop of intensifying international competition between global players and international conflicts, small and poor countries are forced to look for mechanisms to ensure sovereignty and stability, including through the development of scientific and educational sovereignty. Therefore, the question becomes relevant: under what conditions can universities become effective subjects of international relations and help their states increase competitiveness? The status of universities as subjects of international relations is determined by the degree of their international subjectivity. International subjectivity is defined as the ability of universities to independently, regardless of the requirements of external foreign actors, determine the vectors and policies of international cooperation based on the norms, principles, goals and values of national educational systems. The authors of the article describe the conditions and indicators of such subjectivity. The mechanisms for integrating universities into international relations are considered: internationalization of the academic environment, participation in international associations; international rating. The positive aspects, opportunities, risks and contradictions of introducing these mechanisms into national educational systems are identified. Using the experience of Russian universities as an example, it is shown how, under critical conditions, these mechanisms become instruments of political pressure. Based on statistics, analysis of government decisions and the practice of universities in Kyrgyzstan, their potential as subjects of international relations are analyzed. It has been proven that now and in the near future, Kyrgyz universities will be located on the periphery of the global educational space, but have great potential for regional leadership. Kyrgyzstan needs to focus on developing this potential in the near future.

1. Abakirova G.B. Reforms of higher education in Kyrgyzstan and international integration. Issues of sustainable development of society. 2021; 4:495-500. DOI: 10.34755/IROK.2021.51.41.100. EDN VLURSR. [In Russian]

2. Alymbekov K.A. Problems of higher education for the quality assurance system in Kyrgyzstan // Modern problems of science and education: materials of international scientific conferences held by the Academy of Natural Sciences (ongoing edition), France (Paris) - Amsterdam (Netherlands)-Israel (Tel-Aviv)-Russia (Moscow)-UAE (Dubai)-Italy (Rome-Florence-Naples)-Czech Republic (Prague), December 19, 2017 – December 16, 2018. Volume I. France (Paris)-Amsterdam (Netherlands)-Israel (Tel Aviv)-Russia (Moscow)-UAE (Dubai)-Italy (Rome-Florence-Naples)-Czech Republic (Prague): Publishing House of the Academy of Natural Sciences, 2018:21-23. EDN XPZBRR. [In Russian]

3. Bedelbaeva A.Z. Issues of integration of higher professional education of Kyrgyzstan into the global educational space // Science, new technologies and innovations of Kyrgyzstan. 2020; 8:154-159. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=45620356 EDN TPRVPA.

4. The future of higher education and the academic profession: BRICS countries and the USA. Moscow: Publishing house. House of the Higher School of Economics, 2014:247. [In Russian]

5. Kadyralieva N.Sh. Problems of higher historical education in Kyrgyzstan 1991-2021. Historical science and education in the 21^st century: Collection of materials from the II International Scientific and Practical Conference with elements of a scientific school. In memory of Doct. Sc (Hist.), Professor N.N. Rodigina, Novosibirsk, March 22–25, 2023 / Ed. by V.A. Zvereva.Novosibirsk: Novosibirsk State Pedagogical University, 2023:206-215. EDN TVTJXM. [In Russian]

6. Kadyrov A.A. Ideas about science and education and the state of higher education in Kyrgyzstan. Science, new technologies and innovations of Kyrgyzstan. 2021; 5: 153-156. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?edn=DOFIGY. EDN DOFIGY. [In Kyrgyz]

7. Komleva V.V. Internationalization of higher education as a provoking factor in the intensification of competition between national educational systems. Russia and the world : dialogues. Materials of the scientific and practical conference (Moscow, April 24, 2017). Moscow: Publishing House “Scientific Library”, 2017:622. [In Russian]

8. Komleva V.V. Contradictions of the internationalization of higher education. Socio-economic phenomena and processes. 2017; 12 (6):469-477. EDN YNXGNW. URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/protivorechiya-internatsionalizatsii-vysshego-obrazovaniya [In Russian]

9. Komleva V.V. Development of export of Russian higher education: main contradictions. Questions of Political Science. 2020; Vol. 10, 6(58):1899-1907. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?edn=ENTKGR. EDN ENTKGR. [In Russian]

10. Komleva V.V. Russia in the context of new global trends in the internationalization of higher education. Central Russian Bulletin of Social Sciences. 2017; 12 (6):13-34. [In Russian]

11. Communication modes of neighboring countries. Friendliness rating – 2022. Report on the results of annual monitoring/ Scientifically edited by V.V. Komleva. Moscow: National Research Institute for the Communications Development, 2023:104. ISSN 978-5-7151-0597-4 Available from: https://nicrus.ru/publishing/ [In Russian]

12. Mametova M.R. State educational policy in the field of higher education of independent Kyrgyzstan in the context of globalization. In: Global Science and Innovations: Central Asia. 2021; 16(12):39-44. EDN KSKZCI. [In Russian]

13. Mass higher education. BRICS triumph? Moscow: Publishing house “House of the Higher School of Economics”, 2014:528. [In Russian]

14. Mekhamedieva K.A. Formation of educational potential in the conditions of internationalization of the higher education system in Kyrgyzstan. Economics. Control. Education. 2018; 3(6):150-154. EDN LYSEHW. [In Russian]

15. Murzaliev M.A. The higher education system of Kyrgyzstan is a political mechanism and a condition for the integration of the international education system. Bulletin of Osh State University. 2021; 2 (3):78-86. DOI 10.52754/16947452_2021_2_3_78. EDN KEGWTK. [In Kyrgyz]

16. Musaev A.I. Kyrgyz-Russian relations in the field of higher education: state and prospects. Alatoo Academic Studies. 2020; 4:112-121. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?edn=NLIRVS. EDN NLIRVS. [In Russian]

17. Omuraliev U.K. Internationalization of higher education in Kyrgyzstan: from academic mobility to joint educational programs. Economics. Control. Education. 2019; 1(8):130-135. EDN MLXLQK. [In Russian]

18. Problematic tasks of digitalization of the higher education system of Kyrgyzstan / B. I. Biybosunov, Zh. T. Beksultanov, K. M. Yusupov, Zh. Zhumalieva. Colloquium-Journal. 2020; 6-1(58):5-8. DOI: 10.24411/2520-6990-2020-11440. EDN QORKJZ. [In Russian]

19. Samarov A. Modern higher education in Kyrgyzstan and Japan (comparative analysis). Zhusup Balasagyn atyndagy Kyrgyz uluttuk universityinin Zharchysy. 2022; 2(110):158-170. EDN FKWMJF. [In Kyrgyz]

20. Samarov A. Methodological relations between Kyrgyzstan and the Japanese higher education system // Kyrgyzstandin Zharchysy. 2023; 1-1:82-88. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?edn=KOWODB. EDN KOWODB. [In Kyrgyz]

21. Samarov A. Comparative analysis of higher education systems in Kyrgyzstan and Japan. Pedagogical Sciences. 2022; 4(116): 25-27. EDN UGDLGT. [In Russian]

22. Sayakova S.Sh. Development of export of educational services in Kyrgyzstan in the context of globalization and Eurasian integration. Alatoo Academic Studies. 2020; 4:167-175. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?edn=QLKKYN. EDN QLKKYN. [In Russian]

23. Stoletov I.A., Chikharev O.V. Universities as subjects of public diplomacy. Geopolitical Journal. 2013; 2:. 65-78. URL: https://elibrary.ru/download/elibrary_22611972_51865823.pdf [In Russian]

24. Subanov T.T. Current problems of the higher education system of Kyrgyzstan in the conditions of the economic crisis. Greater Eurasia: Development, security, cooperation: A yearbook. Moscow, October 06–07, 2021; 5 (1). Moscow: Institute of Scientific Information for Social Sciences of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 2022: 1084-1086. EDN MXMTNK. [In Russian]

25. Taalaibekova A.T. Interaction between Kyrgyzstan and Russia in the spheres of higher education and science. Bulletin of the Diplomatic Academy of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Kyrgyz Republic named after Kazy Dikambaev. 2021; 16: 169-174. EDN OZPPOO. [In Russian]

26. Sherov Sh.B. Higher education in Kyrgyzstan and its preparation for the requirements of global integration. International Journal of Humanities and Natural Sciences. 2022; 2-2(65):71-74. DOI: 10.24412/2500-1000-2022-2-2-71-74. EDN OFZVMU. [In Russian]

27. Eskindarov M.A., Perskaya V.V. Internationalization of education as a factor in increasing the quality of world-class labor resources. Social and Labor Research. 2021;. 3(44):84-98. DOI: 10.34022/2658-3712-2021-44-3-84-98. EDN JSFEHT.

28. Knight J., Wit H. de. Internationalization of higher education: past and future // International higher education. 2018; 95:2-4. [In English]

29. Murzaliev M.A. Prerequisites and conditions for the development of integration processes in the field of higher education in Kyrgyzstan // International Journal of Humanities and Natural Sciences. 2021; 7(58): 56-60. DOI: 10.24412/2500-1000-2021-7-56-60. EDN WLFRMV. [In English]