The Role of Institutions in the Civilization Schism (the Case of Christianity)

The geopolitical transformations of recent decades have added to the topicality of the study оf civilizational differences between the East and the West relevant. Religion is often cited as a contributing factor to these differences. This can be confirmed by the example of the split of the Christian Church into the Roman Catholic and Orthodox churches and, as a consequence, the emergence of the Western and the Eastern Christian civilizations. As a rule, the authors “isolate” religion from the social system, considering it independently of all other spheres, as the primary factor that triggers the emergence of civilization. In this work, the emergence of a new Western and Eastern Christian, is considered within the framework of the institutional approach, as a process of formation of a certain complex institutional structure that regulates the life of society and consists of a whole complex of interconnected and interdependent economic, political, and socio-cultural institutions, including religion. This process can begin in the bowels of the “mother” civilization, causing its crisis. The stages of development and resolution of such a crisis are analyzed using the example of a split in the united Christian world using a matrix approach. This approach assumes that civilization is characterized by a civilizational matrix formed by an institutional core that simultaneously contains market and redistributive institutions on the basis of dominance/complementarity, and a shell that includes cultural-religious and national-demographic characteristics, the naturalclimatic and material-technological environment. The necessity of both strengthening dominant institutions in the institutional core and creating balancers (complementary institutions) for the sustainable development of civilization is shown.

1. Barakhvostov P.A. Features of the civilizational frontier: an integral institutional analysis. Vesnіk Grodzenskaga dzjarzhaўnaga unіversіtjeta іmja Jankі Kupaly. Seryja 1. History and archaeology. Philosophy. 2020; 12 (1) 119-126 [In Russian].

2. Bolotov V.V. History of the Church during the period of the Ecumenical Councils: History of theological thought. Moscow: Pokolenie, 2007 [In Russian].

3. Brodsky I. Form of the time. T. 2. Minsk: Eridan, 1992 [In Russian].

4. Boyer R., Brousseau E., Kaye A. Towards an Institutional Political Economy creation. Jekonomicheskaja sociologija. 2008; 9 (3):17–24. [In Russian].

5. Burlaka D. K. Religion and Church. Vestnik Russkoj hristianskoj gumanitarnoj akademii. 2005; 6: 7–54 [In Russian].

6. Vasiliev L.S. Evolution laws and problems of Mankind: preprint WP17/2011/03. Мoscow: Izdatel’skij dom Vysshej shkoly jekonomiki, 2011 [In Russian].

7. Gergey E. History of the papacy. Moscow: Republic, 1996 [In Russian].

8. Gumilyov L.N. Ancient Rus’ and the Great Steppe. Moscow: Mysl’, 1989 [In Russian].

9. Danilevsky N.Ya. Russia and the Europe: A look at the cultural and political relations of the Slavic world to the German-Romance] St. Petersburg: N. Strakhov, 1895 [In Russian].

10. Dementyev V.V. Institutional political economy: where to start? Zhurnal institucional’nyh issledovanij. 2015; 7 (1):25-44 [In Russian]. DOI: 10.17835/2076-6297.2015.7.1.025-044.

11. Callistus W. The Orthodox Church. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Duh i Litera, 2004 [In Russian].

12. Kirdina S.G. Institutional Matrices and Russia’s Development: An Introduction to X-Y Theory. St. Petersburg: Nestor-History, 2014 [In Russian].

13. Kostromin K.A. The division of churches in the context of pan-European international politics in the 9th–12th centuries. Vestnik Russkoj hristianskoj gumanitarnoj akademii. 2015; 14 (1):14-22 [In Russian].

14. Le Goff J. Birth of the Europe. St. Petersburg: Alexandria, 2008 [In Russian].

15. Lebedev A.P. The churches division history of the 9th, 10th and 11th centuries. Moscow: RUGRAM_ Palmira, 2022 [In Russian].

16. Leontiev K.N. Byzantium and Slavism. Selected works. Moscow: Rarog, Moscow Worker, 1993 [In Russian].

17. Litavrin G.G. Geopolitical position of Byzantium in the medieval world in the VII–XII centuries. Vizantija mezhdu Zapadom i Vostokom. Opyt istoricheskoj harakteristiki. Saint-Petersburg, Aletejja, 2001 [In Russian].

18. Martynov О.P. On the reasons for the divergence of the worldviews of the Christian East and West. Rjazanskij bogoslovskij vestnik. 2018; (2):54–68 [In Russian].

19. Orlov М. Religious and cultural factor as a condition for the transformation of international and legal relations. Vlast’, 2008; (5): 66–69 [In Russian].

20. Perepelkin L.S. Phobias in the Europe as a mechanism of intercivilizational disengagement. Voprosy social’noj teorii: Nauchnyj al’manah. 2018; 10: 80-89 [In Russian]. DOI: 10.30936/222779512018108089.

21. Posnov M.E. Christian Church History (before the division of the Churches – 1054). Kyiv: Christian. Charitable-educational association «Put’ k istine», 1991 [In Russian].

22. Runciman S. Eastern schism. Byzantine theocracy. Moscow: Vostochnaja literature, 1998 [In Russian].

23. Salnikov V.P., Romanovskaya L.R. “Orient” or “oxident”: which way is the Russian eagle facing? Mir politiki i sociologii. 2014; (11):11–15 [In Russian].

24. Sinaisky A. St. Petersburg: Tipografija Sankt-Peterburgskogo akcionernogo obshhestva “Izdatel’”, 1899 [In Russian].

25. Toynbee A.J. Civilization on trial the world and the west. Moscow: AST, 2011 [In Russian].

26. Treushnikov I.A. The main aspects of the problem “West – East” in the historiosophy of the unity. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta, Serija 7. Filosofija. 2009; (2):30–40 [In Russian].

27. Filonov V.I. The Orthodoxy and Catholicism Relationship in the context of the Europe ethnocultural self-identity: historical and political aspect. Vestnik gosudarstvennogo i municipal’nogo upravlenija. 2017; (2):120–123 [In Russian].

28. Florya B.N. At the origins of the religious schism of the Slavic world (XIII century). St. Petersburg: Aletheya, 2004 [In Russian].

29. Fries V. Orthodoxy and Catholicism. Opposite or complementary? Brussels: Zhizn’s Bogom, God, 1992 [In Russian].

30. Shishova M.I. The problem of relations between the state and the church in the religious and philosophical concept of the metaphysics of culture. Vestnik Russkoj hristianskoj gumanitarnoj akademii. 2014; 15 (4): 260–267 [In Russian].

31. Schmemann A. All the monarchs of the world: Ancient Greece, Ancient Rome, Byzantium / Ed.K. Ryzhova. Мoscow, Veche, 1999 [In Russian].

32. Spengler O. The Decline of Europe: Essays on the Morphology of World History. Moscow: Mysl, 1993 [In Russian].

33. Barakhvostov P. The Inheritance Rights in the Process of Formation and Evolution of Institutional Matrices. Mir Rossii. 2022, 31(2):163–173 [In English]. DOI: 10.17323/1811-038X-2022-31-2-163-173.

34. Beck U. Risk Society Revisited: Theory, Politics and Research Programmes. The risk society and beyond: critical issues for social theory / B. Adam, U. Beck, J. Van Loon (Eds.). London: Sage Publications. 2007:211–230 [In English].

35. Hodgson G.M. What is the essence of institutional economics? Journal of Economic Issues. 2000. 34 (2):317–329 [In English].

36. North D.C. Institutions. Journal of Economic Perspectives. 1991; 5 (1):97–112 [In English].

37. Wittfogel К.A. Oriental Despotism. Comparative study of total power. New Haven, London: Yale University Press, 1963 [In English].